Documentation & Traininge-LearningMarketingIT Development
vip-global.com, Virtual Intelligence Providers, VIP
VIP Partners
VIP IT Development, Application Development, Databases, SQL, Oracle, Java. SEIBEL, ASP
VIP e-Learning Comparison Costs

Traditional
 


 E-Learning
Development Time(days) per Course Day (Typical Ratio 10 Days for 1 Day)
days
Development Time(days) per Course Day (Typical Ratio 50- 100 Days for 1 Day) days
NR of Students Same in both Situations
NR of Teaching Resources
(Count Resources Present During the Class)
NR of Teaching Resources
(Count Resources Present During Remote Coaching)
NR of Course Days NR of Course Days
(should be less than the traditional, usually half)
days
Student Daily Cost
currency
Same in both Situations
Teacher Daily Cost
currency
Same in both Situations
Daily Classroom Cost
currency
Daily Communication Costs per Student or Network Use
(count one day telecom connection, around 12 USD per day)
currency
Daily Travel Cost per Student or Teacher
currency
Coaching Time per Student (in hours)
(the time spent on individual monitoring, f.i
if the course is 1 day count 20 minutes = .3 hours)
hours
Daily Accomodation Cost per Student
currency
Admin Cost (hours) per Student per Course hours
Printed Material Cost per Student
currency
Computer Equipment Purchase Price per student  currency
Admin Cost(hours) per Student per Course
hours
Total Traditional Costs (currency) Total E-Learning Costs (currency)
   
Your Savings (currency)  
Your Savings in Percent       


Assumptions


We had to make a few assumptions for this model:

- Development effort expressed as a ratio = number of days development per day of training produced. In both cases we took the worst situation, e.g the assumption that the courses are delivered once. Usually, it is not the case, they can be reused. Make sure you include here all development efforts. If you use subcontractors, express their costs in terms of "instructor days" to simplify.

- One comment about the development ratio for the e-Learning column. A rule of thumb is around 20 days per day for a simple but high quality course (including pedagogic concepts, design, production, tests). The more you add interactivity, sophisticated navigation, rich multimedia content, data bases,... the more this ratio will grow. So you could reach as much as 200 to one for a highly sophisticated piece of work.

- The model shows a "make" situation. There are other situations, where you buy existing titles.

- We identified key resources usage, such as the classroom renting, accomodation and travel in the case of traditional training, and share of computer/network/platform usage in the case of E-Learning, although very often the students use the e-mail network and computers.

- If in your particular case, you feel that a mixed situation should happen (such as traditional classes during an e-Learning curriculum), just substract the equivalent to the left column, to balance correctly.

- As far as the course days number is concerned, there is now ample evidence that one needs less e-Learning hours than hours in a class. Assume at least 20 % savings. This measures the effectiveness of the e-Learning approach: less time, better retention ratio, more practice.

- We added admin costs in both cases. It should cover enrollment, student admin, etc... (feel free to add here any overhead you may think of).

 

Copyright © 2001 - 2008 Virtual Intelligence Providers - info@vip-global.com